How Do HOA Boards Approve Roofing Bids?
Quick Answer
HOA boards approve roofing bids by collecting a minimum of 3 competitive bids from licensed contractors, reviewing per-building line-item pricing, verifying reserve fund balance, and holding a formal board vote requiring a simple or supermajority depending on association bylaws. The full process typically takes 30–90 days from RFP issuance to signed contract. For projects exceeding the reserve fund cap or bylaw threshold, a homeowner membership vote may also be required.
Step 1: Document the Need (Days 1–14)
Before requesting bids, the board should commission a third-party roof condition assessment — typically a drone roof report plus a moisture survey for flat roofs. This document forms the factual basis for the replacement decision and protects board members from owner challenges later.
Step 2: Issue an RFP (Days 14–28)
The RFP should specify: roof type and approximate square footage by building, scope (tear-off + replace vs. overlay), required underlayment and ventilation upgrades, warranty requirements (e.g., GAF Golden Pledge), insurance requirements ($5M GL minimum for multi-building HOAs), and the response deadline. Send to at least 5 contractors — expect 3 responses.
Step 3: Review Bids with Per-Building Line Items (Days 28–45)
Reject lump-sum bids — they prevent apples-to-apples comparison. Real HOA bids show line items for each building: roof square footage, decking allowance, underlayment, ice-and-water shield, ventilation, flashing, gutters, and accessories. Unit pricing for hidden conditions ($X per square foot for deck replacement, $X per linear foot of fascia) protects the HOA from change-order surprises.
Step 4: Reference Check Each Finalist (Days 30–45)
Call at least 3 HOA references from each finalist’s past 24 months of work. Ask: Did they finish on schedule? Were there change orders? Did they communicate proactively? Would you hire them again? Skip references and you’ll likely regret it.
Step 5: Board Vote (Days 45–60)
The vote requirement depends on association bylaws. Most HOAs allow the board to approve roofing contracts up to a dollar threshold (often $50,000–$500,000) with a simple majority. Above that threshold, a membership vote may be required. Check the declaration BEFORE the vote — challenges to authority can void the contract.
Step 6: Sign Contract and Schedule (Days 60–90)
Standard HOA roofing contracts include AIA A105 or A107 base, payment schedule (10/40/40/10 is typical), lien waivers from subs and suppliers, the certificate of insurance naming the association as additional insured, the warranty paperwork, and a permit pull commitment from the contractor.
Related Questions HOA Boards Ask
- How many bids does an HOA need for a roof replacement?
- What majority does an HOA board need to approve a roof contract?
- When does an HOA roof replacement need a homeowner vote?
Get a Free HOA Roofing Consultation
No pressure. No sales pitch. Just answers to your HOA’s roofing questions from a Minnesota specialist.